European Court of Human Rights' verdicts binding for CE members

Slovakia's Supreme Court decided in favour of Slovakia’s lower courts on June 13 and against the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg. The lower courts fined a journalist Sk15,000 (€440) in 1997 for violating the libel law - despite the fact that the European court ruled last autumn that the Slovak courts had violated Martin Klein's rights as a journalist, the Sme daily reported on June 14.

The courts in Košice found Klein guilty of libel for an article he wrote in the Domino Efekt weekly about Bratislava-Trnava Archbishop Ján Sokol, after the latter had appeared on television in 1997.

"This primate of the first Christian Church (Sokol) has even less virtue than the leader of the worst gypsy string quartet,” Klein wrote. “I can't understand why decent Christians don't leave the organization with such a monster at the helm."

Church organizations sued Klein for defaming the convictions of the faithful. The Košice district court sentenced him in 2000 to pay the aforementioned fine or spend a year in prison. This ruling was later upheld by the Košice regional court.

In March this year, however, Klein received more than Sk380,000 in compensation including legal fees in accordance with the European Court's ruling.

According to the head of the Slovak Supreme Court Office Eva Rupcová, however, "there is no connection between the country's domestic courts and the court in Strasbourg".

Lawyer Jozef Vozár of the State and Law Institute disagrees however, saying that the Strasbourg court's rulings are binding for Slovak courts.

Compiled by Zuzana Vilikovská from press reports
The Slovak Spectator cannot vouch for the accuracy of the information presented in its Flash News postings.

Top stories

Finance Minister Peter Kažimír

Draft budget curtails deficit below 2 percent

THE BUDGET deficit should continue decreasing in following three years, according to the first public administration budget draft introduced by the Finance Ministry on July 23.

Crash site

New facts about fatal helicopter crash emerge

THE THREE members of a military helicopter MI-17 crew were training winching up people into helicopter with the help of a rope not practicing landings, when they crashed on July 28 afternoon near Prešov.

Stanislav Boledovič

Teach for Slovakia chief talks education reform

STANISLAV Boledovič, the founder of the Teach for Slovakia project, believes that it helps socially disadvantages children succeed.

Police President Tibor Gašpar

Harabin releases third convicted police officer

Another police officer convicted for corruption was released by the appellate senate chaired by Štefan Harabin with the argument that the police inspectorate that investigated his case is unlawful. The former…

MOST READ ARTICLES


  1. Slovakia’s ‘invisible minority’ counters migration fears
  2. US convoy will pass through Slovakia to NATO drill in Hungary
  3. Slovak-Austrian border development project gets €89 million
  4. Slovak among languages featured in new Google tool
  5. Slovnaft to take over the Agip petrol stations
  6. Teach for Slovakia chief talks education reform
  7. New facts about fatal helicopter crash emerge
  8. The biggest Roma festival in Slovakia spills into Bratislava streets
  9. SMK party: Dunajská Streda fans beaten up, Kaliňák must act
  10. Harabin releases third convicted police officer
  1. Slovakia’s ‘invisible minority’ counters migration fears
  2. The biggest Roma festival in Slovakia spills into Bratislava streets
  3. Helicopter crash claims one life
  4. Land Rover may go to Poland, British media report
  5. Slovakia and migrants
  6. Average salary now €929 per month
  7. Slovnaft to take over the Agip petrol stations
  8. US convoy will pass through Slovakia to NATO drill in Hungary
  9. Let's not allow ethnic conflicts to spread in Europe
  10. Kia Motors Slovakia plant makes 3 millionth engine
  1. Slovakia and migrants
  2. Slovakia’s ‘invisible minority’ counters migration fears
  3. Average salary now €929 per month
  4. Greece submits diplomatic protest against Kažimír’s comments
  5. Volkswagen Slovakia is the company’s best plant
  6. Record heat wave tests infrastructure, patience
  7. The biggest Roma festival in Slovakia spills into Bratislava streets
  8. Four die in rescue helicopter crash
  9. Helicopter crash claims one life
  10. Slovak auction house sold original bust by Bernini