Council of Europe concerned over new judicial law

THE INTRODUCTION of obligatory security clearances for judges might breach international standards, according to the Council of Europe’s body concerning the independence, competence, and impartiality of judges.

THE INTRODUCTION of obligatory security clearances for judges might breach international standards, according to the Council of Europe’s body concerning the independence, competence, and impartiality of judges.

The Consultative Council of European Judges (CCJE), which the CoE established in 2000, stated in its opinion on the recently passed amendment to Slovakia’s Constitution which, among other changes of rules for the work of judges, introduces compulsory security clearances for all judges.

“CCJE in its statement states that the international standards will be breached if the conditions will be widened by adding the possibility to recall a judge from their post in case they are evaluated as not fulfilling the prerequisites of judges’ competence,” Slovakia’s representative in CCJE Alena Poláčková, who requested the organisation’s opinion, said as quoted by the TASR newswire.

CCJE deems the stable term of a judge to be the main element of a judge’s independence, meaning that the only reason for a judge to be recalled, apart from health reasons or achieving the given age, is a sentence in a penal procedure or in a disciplinary procedure.

Not even the fact that the Judicial Council is supposed to evaluate the clearances secures an impartial process, since the Council “is not a judicial body and definitely not politically independent”, Poláčková said as quoted by TASR.

CCJE also expressed concerns about the gathering of documentation from secret services for the purposes of the clearances of judges.

“We all know that the secret services have their own very specific ways of gathering information which are absolutely non-transparent,” Poláčková said, adding that the CCJE believes this would create pressure on the judiciary and violate the principle of the presumption of innocence.

“These clearances will impact the division of power in the state,” Poláčková further stated as quoted by TASR. “A democratic state is characterised by the fact that there is an equal division of power between the executive, the legislative, and the judiciary. As soon as the executive is put in a position from which it controls the judiciary, we are no longer talking about a democratic state but rather a police state.”

Source: TASR

Compiled by Michaela Terenzani from press reports.
The Slovak Spectator cannot vouch for the accuracy of the information
presented in its Flash News postings.

Top stories

The referendum is said to protect traditional families.
Politics & society

Turnout key to referendum result

EVEN amid heated discussion about the content of a February 7 referendum targeting the constitutional definition of family, experts say the biggest test for supporters of the Alliance for Family (AZR) ballot initiative is whether turnout surpasses the required 50-percent quorum of eligible voters.

26. Jan 2015
One of the drugs to be withdrawn from pharmacies.
Business

Eleven generic drugs withdrawn from Slovak pharmacies

Slovak State Institute for Drug Control (ŠÚKL) on January 28 suspended the distribution of 11 generic drugs and withdrew them from the market.

29. Jan 2015
Krásna Hôrka Castle ablaze.
Culture & lifestyle

Reconstruction on Krásna Hôrka Castle continues

THE RECONSTRUCTION works on the Krásna Hôrka Castle, which was severely damaged by fire in 2012, continue in accordance with the plans, Judita Krajčiová of the Slovak National Museum (SNM) told the TASR newswire.

27. Jan 2015
Tom Nicholson
Opinion

Economy Minister Pavlis has to go

No one with such an obvious conflict of interest has any place in government.

30. Jan 2015