Via Iuris: 30 percent of new judges linked to current judges or court officials

VIA IURIS judicial watchdog conducted a monitoring and analysis exercise last year in which it found that as many as 30 percent of newly-appointed judges have close family ties with incumbent judges or court employees.

VIA IURIS judicial watchdog conducted a monitoring and analysis exercise last year in which it found that as many as 30 percent of newly-appointed judges have close family ties with incumbent judges or court employees.

The organisation is convinced that systemic changes in the selection of new judges could prevent nepotism. Justice Minister Tomáš Borec could contribute to this easily and quickly enough by appointing non-judges as members of commissions in charge of selecting new judges, the TASR newswire quoted from the organisation’s press release.

“The analysis that’s been drawn up contains recommendations on changes in the selection procedures for judges,” Kristína Babiaková, a lawyer working with Via Iuris, said on July 22. “These recommendations include changes in the composition of the selection commission, determining specific criteria for the choice of a selection commission and the Judicial Council alike, and the introduction of balance in the written and oral parts of the selection procedure. These and other measures that are set forth in detail in the analysis would to a great extent remove doubts regarding objectivity in the selection of judges.”

Via Iuris “ignores the recent ruling of the Constitutional Court which deemed part of the rules for tenders adopted in 2011 unconstitutional,” Justice Ministry spokeswoman Alexandra Donevová said. “It would not be good to apply these rules; and thus no change of candidates for members of selection committees would be appropriate.”

(Source: TASR)
Compiled by Zuzana Vilikovská from press reports
The Slovak Spectator cannot vouch for the accuracy of the information presented in its Flash News postings.

Top stories

Police President Tibor Gašpar

Harabin releases third convicted police officer

Another police officer convicted for corruption was released by the appellate senate chaired by Štefan Harabin with the argument that the police inspectorate that investigated his case is unlawful. The former…

The Vietnamese community is well integrated.

Slovakia’s ‘invisible minority’ counters migration fears

Immigration has been at the centre of Slovakia’s public discourse in recent weeks, and though it may seem so, the issue is hardly a new one. Vietnamese people, for instance, have lived in Slovakia since the 1970s…

Ombudswoman Jana Dubovcová

Police deny racially-motivated raids

OMBUDSWOMAN Jana Dubovcová points to an excessive number of searching actions in regions with numerous Roma communities demanding Police President Tibor Gašpar to check if they are racially motivated, but he denies…

Helicopter crash claims one life

A PILOT died and another two soldiers were injured in the military helicopter crash on July 28.