Spectator on facebook

Spectator on facebook

Reader feedback: Torn over conscientious objection

Re: KDH and SDKÚ face clash over Vatican Treaty, Flash News Briefs, February 6 - February 12, 2006

To a certain extent, I am torn on the provision that would allow doctors to refuse to perform abortions on religious grounds.

On the one hand, I believe that, in a free society, no physician should be forced for any reason to perform procedures they find morally objectionable.

On the other hand, though, I adamantly hold that abortions must remain safe and legal in order for women to truly be free. I do not believe that the government should play a role in making this difficult decision for women, outside of guaranteeing the safety and licensing standards of medical professionals.

What tips the scale for me is the fact that democracy is based on certain fundamental principles: in order for a government by the people and for the people to function, there must be separation of church - an extremely influential institution in many people's lives, even without legislative powers - and state.

Certainly Slovakia is a predominantly Catholic country, but that is precisely the reason I would question any decision to sign the Vatican Treaty, a document which most certainly smacks of state sponsorship of a specific religion. In order to protect the religious rights of the minority, Slovakia must NOT endorse the Vatican point of view.

M. Shantyhag,
USA

The processing of personal data is subject to our Privacy Policy and the Cookie Policy. Before submitting your e-mail address, please make sure to acquaint yourself with these documents.

Top stories

Slovak healthcare needs thousands of medical workers

Slovak doctors, nurses and midwives are not hesitating in finding better work conditions abroad.

Illustrative Stock Photo

Fight with traffickers thwarted online sale of hockey tickets

The algorithm not only prevented traffickers but also ordinary fans from buying tickets.

Waiting for tickets in Košice

Spectacular Slovakia #3: Unexpected hiking (Enjoy Bratislava's greenery) Audio

In Slovakia, you can hike in the capital city. Listen to the latest episode of our travel podcast to find out more.

Institutions can be quickly destroyed, but they are hard to build

Head of the To Dá Rozum intiative, Renáta Hall, talks about the impacts of a dispute between the academy of sciences and the Education Ministry.

Renáta Hall