Spectator on facebook

Spectator on facebook

Court above the law

Public officials and state bodies are upholding an old tradition - if they find that a law is inconvenient for them to obey, they ignore it. It is a scandal, however, that one of the state bodies behaving in such a way is the Constitutional Court, and for its second term.

Public officials and state bodies are upholding an old tradition - if they find that a law is inconvenient for them to obey, they ignore it. It is a scandal, however, that one of the state bodies behaving in such a way is the Constitutional Court, and for its second term.

The law says that court cases must be assigned to judges "in random order with the assistance of technical and program means". At the regional and district court level, in the past this meant the introduction of electronic case assignment systems. At the Supreme Court, former chief justice Štefan Harabin fought this tooth and nail, but following his departure this failing was put right. If now we were to ask whether it is right for this system to be introduced to the Constitutional Court as well, we would probably hear many arguments against it, claiming that it makes more sense for the court's management to distribute the 2,000 cases that arrive every year in a way that ensures each justice will be equally burdened.

However, this is not the question that should be asked. Just like the regular courts, the Constitutional Court also faces the legal obligation to assign cases electronically. The fact that the court has not done this, from August 2004 under former Chief Justice Ján Mazák and now under new Chief Justice Ivetta Macejková, is shocking. If an independent court that is in charge of protecting constitutionality in this country refuses to obey the law, this is an unheard-of failing. An organ that is tasked by the Constitution with demanding and enforcing the observance of the law cannot do that which it forbids other courts. Even if the court is convinced the law prevents it from acting effectively, it is entitled to demand the law be changed, but it must still obey what the law says. Otherwise it destroys what it was set up to protect.


Sme, April 3

Top stories

No Slovaks among the victims of Manchester attack so far

The representatives of Slovakia have expressed their sympathy to the families of the victims.

Police guard close to the Manchester Arena in Manchester, Britain, on May 23, 2017, a day after an explosion.

It's not your Slovakia, Bystrica protesters told Kotleba

President Andrej Kiska spoke to the crowd at the protest gathering, asking Slovaks what kind of country they want to have.

Lajčák gives two versions of the Evka story

The Foreign Ministry gives opposing statements about suspicious procurement related to the Slovak Presidency over the EU Council.

Government of PM Robert Fico (left) endorses Lajčák as its official candidate.

Napoleon’s oak planted in Bratislava's Tyršovo Embankment Photo

An oak of Napoleonic legend was replanted, part of a commemoration spanning several days.

Planting "Naopoleon's oak" on May 20, 2017.