Spectator on facebook

Spectator on facebook

Against legislators

Lawyers Valko and Trimaj wrote on this page two weeks ago that both regular courts and the Constitutional Court are required to ensure a randomly appointed judge on each case they handle, but that the latter court is still assigning cases to judges on a subjective basis. Chief Justice Ivetta Macejková responded that unlike lower courts, which have to use an electronic case assignment system to ensure a random selection, the Constitutional Court "is not required to by law". She added that the Constitutional Court has a specific position that prevents it from "mechanically adopting the same electronic means of case assignment as the lower courts". Her standpoint is not only in conflict with the opinions of these two constitutional law experts, but also with the intentions of legislators.

In April 2004, the parliamentary Constitutional Law Committee presented an amendment to get rid of the difference in the way judges were chosen at regular courts and the Constitutional Court, saying the latter had to ensure case assignment "by random selection with the aid of technical and program aids". The Committee said the change was necessary in order to guarantee people their right to a lawfully chosen judge, and in order to avoid the risk of people suing Slovakia on that very score. If the European Court of Human Rights does uphold a complaint regarding the Constitutional Court's failure to provide a lawfully selected judge, Slovakia will be faced with a big problem - and one that it has known about for almost three years.


Sme, April 10

Top stories

When the state can’t keep a secret

A selective leak has tarnished President Kiska’s reputation. But he must continue to speak out about corruption.

President Andrej Kiska

Austria launches random checks close to Slovakia’s borders

Refugees are using new smuggling routes, according to the Austrian minister.

Illustrative stock photo

Unemployment rate continues to decline

The still steeper fall in unemployment could be curbed by the type of jobseekers, analysts opine.

Carmakers have already complained about the lack of qualified labour.

Coalition only agrees on how to talk. But what will they talk about?

Budget talks to decide on concrete policies. Danko wants airplanes, Fico wants better pay for nights and weekends.

Danko, Fico, Bugar.