Spectator on facebook

Spectator on facebook

A mistaken confession

When asked by the moderator of a TV talk show whether they believed Hedviga Malinová, an ethnic Hungarian student who claims to have been beaten up by Slovak extremists last year, or the police, who say the incident never happened, guests Béla Bugár (SMK) and Viliam Veteška (HZDS) fell into the trap, with Bugár declaring for Malinová, and Veteška for the police.

When asked by the moderator of a TV talk show whether they believed Hedviga Malinová, an ethnic Hungarian student who claims to have been beaten up by Slovak extremists last year, or the police, who say the incident never happened, guests Béla Bugár (SMK) and Viliam Veteška (HZDS) fell into the trap, with Bugár declaring for Malinová, and Veteška for the police. A responsible politician, however, would have said that he preferred to wait for the facts of the case to come out instead of making a statement based on hearsay.

SMK leader Pál Csáky, like Bugár, likewise said last week that "we believe this girl". In other words, they already have doubts whether the court that will decide the case will be free and fair. This is an immoral position. If, as the lawyer for Malinová says, there is evidence that the police mishandled her case, where better to present it than in court? One thing is for sure - these court proceedings will be under greater domestic and international scrutiny than any until now.

On the other hand, the confession of Veteška is naive and irresponsible as well. Believing that the justice system in Slovakia always acts fairly and decides impartially simply because it is Slovak is not an expression of patriotism but of gullibility. If it is proven in court that Malinová was charged without grounds, it will not be a loss for Slovakia but a victory for the truth.


Sme, May 21

The processing of personal data is subject to our Privacy Policy and the Cookie Policy. Before submitting your e-mail address, please make sure to acquaint yourself with these documents.

Top stories

Biker gang complex in Dolná Krupá raises questions

What does the Russian bikers’ gang Night Wolves do in the Slovak village of Dolná Krupá?

The complex in Dolná Krupá

Blog: How business mentoring can change our schools for the better

Business mentoring benefits both involved parties and has the potential to change Slovak schools for the better.

Junior Achievement Slovakia organises various events, including a fair of student companies.

Here is how I measure the speed of integration

Babiš proposes to end war, poverty and religious extremism with a snap of our fingers. Why hasn’t anybody else thought of this?

Andrej Babiš, Czech prime minister

How rock music helped bring down the totalitarian regime Video

A new film shows that Rock & Roll, forbidden in the Soviet Union, helped to end the Cold War.

Illustrative Stock Photo