Spectator on facebook

Spectator on facebook

Letter to the Editor: Beneš decrees site talk lacks perspective

The feedback provided by Slovak Spectator readers regarding the Beneš Decrees manages to cast Slovakia and Slovaks in the singularly unique role (for Slovakia) of an oppressor, yet no letter brings a more complete perspective to the whole issue of Slovak-Hungarian relations.

First of all, Slovaks do not have a monopoly on racial or any other kind of intolerance, the Tiso government notwithstanding. There is a very long period of Slovak history which saw suppression of Slovaks by the Magyars. This point is basic.

Without falling into the "victim" mentality that your newspaper claims (rightly) Slovaks tend to express, just when do injustices get corrected? And which injustices will they be?

The circumstances of history determine these "corrections", and for the njustice corrected by the Beneš Decrees, the circumstances after World War II were the mitigating ones. How can these be negotiated now? It is tantamount, to use a wild example, of negotiating India back under British rule. There is simply no force of argument available that can distil only the "injustice" of the Beneš Decrees against Hungary, to the exclusion of all the other injustices inflicted in the region since the 5th century.

And if we are to talk of "minority rights", there are far better examples of oppressed minorities in the world than the Hungarians of Slovakia, especially when one realises that the parent country to this minority resides next door with a population twice that of Slovakia and another 5 million (also oppressed?) in other countries of the world. Rather than the ethnic Albanians of Macedonia, to use another wild example, it is more like talking about an "American minority" in Canada.

Peter Knazko
Ottawa, Canada

Top stories

How to sell Slovak books to English readers

Slovak literature makes it to the big bookstores of London, but it is unlikely to become a bestseller yet.

On Wednesday, Slovak literature will be presented in one of the biggest bookstores in London. Among the new books translated into English is also the anthology of current Slovak prose selected and translated by Magdalena Mullek and Júlia Sherwood.

Slovakia vies for medicines agency

What chances does the country have at winning the seat of the prestigious European Medicines Agency that needs to relocate from London?

Illustrative stock photo

Vote-buying scandal lands village mayor in court

Some Roma claiming the mayor of Gemerská Poloma, Miroslav Michalka was buying votes, have changed their testimonies.

Stanislav Kučerák (blue shirt) is a key witness in the vote-buying case.

British embassy opens condolence book

The book will be opened for two days.

Floral tributes are laid out in Manchester, England, on May 23, 2017, the day after the suicide attack at an Ariana Grande concert that left 22 people dead as it ended on May 22 night.