Review: Much panic about nothing

PANIC Room (2002) is a would-be thriller about people spending their first night in a new house. It purports to show what happens when fears, paranoia and nightmares become true. But despite its attractive visual images the film is scuppered by a lack of inspiration, clichés and a predictable ending.
Divorced from a rich businessman, Meg Altman (Jodie Foster) buys an expensive house in New York's Upper West Side. The house used to be inhabited by a deceased millionaire whose fear of being murdered led him to build a 'panic room', a high-tech shelter with a thick steel door, alarms and surveillance monitors.


FOSTER and daughter escape intruders in lift.
photo: Courtesy of Itafilm

Panic Room

Running time: 108 min
Starring: Jodie Foster, Forest Whitaker, Dwight Yoakam, Jared Leto, Kristen Stewart
Directed by: David Fincher
Rating: 3 out of 10
See page 11 for movie times in Slovakia

PANIC Room (2002) is a would-be thriller about people spending their first night in a new house. It purports to show what happens when fears, paranoia and nightmares become true. But despite its attractive visual images the film is scuppered by a lack of inspiration, clichés and a predictable ending.

Divorced from a rich businessman, Meg Altman (Jodie Foster) buys an expensive house in New York's Upper West Side. The house used to be inhabited by a deceased millionaire whose fear of being murdered led him to build a 'panic room', a high-tech shelter with a thick steel door, alarms and surveillance monitors.

The nightmare begins the first day Meg and her diabetic daughter Sarah (Kristen Stewart) move in. Falling asleep after spending a day unpacking their belongings, they are soon awoken by three burglars invading the house in search of millions of dollars left there by the late eccentric owner. The new tenants hastily lock themselves into the panic room, not knowing that what the burglars want is right in that room, and that they will use all means to get it.

The story itself is cheap stuff. Screenplay writer David Koepp obviously chose the easiest way to a quick buck, providing a lot of violence and blood rather than elaborating on the psychological aspects of two people hiding from attackers in a tiny room.

Even the casting cannot rescue such a badly written screenplay. Foster is only a shadow of FBI detective Clarice Starling in the unforgettable thriller The Silence of the Lambs (directed by Jonathan Demme in 1991). Even with the help of digital and video images, no actor can mend the holes in the plot and generate credible tension between victims and intruders, tension that Foster so memorably achieved with pathological killer Dr. Hannibal Lecter (Anthony Hopkins). Her contribution to Panic Room is best forgotten.

If anything deserves being remembered it is the visual effects by David Fincher (Seven, 1995, The Game, 1997). The camera, swiftly moving through walls, zooming up on fascinating details, is the movie's best tool to illustrate the claustrophobia people suffer in a room besieged by murderous enemies. But it's not enough to sustain interest for two hours, far less to justify the cost of a movie ticket.

Top stories

Trenčín covered in Christmas lights on November 29, 2021.

Weekend: Ježiško's Christmas Post Office is open, expecting letters from around the world

Make yourself comfortable and explore what has been going on in Slovakia in the past days.


3. dec

News Digest: Climate in Slovakia could be similar to Italy's in a few decades

Suburban transport in Bratislava Region to improve, registration for regulated parking in Bratislava launched, utility regulator announces price caps for 2022.


23 h
Waydanovský House, today Martineum, after reconstruction.

Historical house near Bratislava cathedral no longer needs to hide behind Van Gogh

The Waydanovský House, now Martineum, will serve as the background facility for St Martin's Cathedral. Take a look at how it looked in the past and now.


1. dec

Culture Ministry looks to create ‘21st century environment’ for Slovak media

Transparency of ownership and financing among proposed overhaul of decades-old laws.


2. dec
Skryť Close ad