Reader feedback: Gone too far

Re: Catholic Church hopes for three new treaties with Vatican, By Martina Pisárová, Vol 8, No 42, Nov 4 to 10

Dear Madam,

The constitutions of both the United States (Amendment 1) and Slovakia (Article 24) both guarantee freedom of religion. However, the difference in the interpretation of these provisions is striking.

The US Supreme Court has ruled that, since a primary purpose of the first amendment is to ensure that no state religion will be established, there must be a "wall of separation" between church and state. Thus, prayer in public schools is prohibited, as are most forms of direct aid to parochial schools and institutions. Even displays of Christmas creches and crucifixes and the singing of religious holiday songs have been banned in government buildings.

In sharp contrast, as your article points out, here in Slovakia the government pays the full salaries of priests and other "religious servants" and even part of the bishops' office expenses. With regard to education, the only debate is whether the state should pay all or just part of church schools' costs, and under the new treaty the Catholic Church will have the right to lecture children "on the Christian faith in all state schools".

The relationship between church and state is a controversial topic all over the world, and emotions run high on both sides. Perhaps the US and Slovakia have each gone too far in opposite directions.

Bill Dzurilla

Get daily Slovak news directly to your inbox

Top stories

News digest: Foreigners’ Police departments remain closed

Slovenia has ordered PCR tests developed by Slovak scientists. Holocaust survivors received the coronavirus vaccine jab.

12 h

Slovakia has more and more vaccines available. State lacks courage

Slovakia is taking a cautious approach to make sure it will be able to deliver second doses when needed.

17 h
Police control at the border crossing in Drietomá (Trenčín Region).

Stricter curfew rules come into force, police intensify checks

Negative test result required when going to work or doing sports in nature.

18 h
The entry of new data is required via Slovensko.sk.

Companies complain about an absurd fee. They need to add information state also has

Firms have to add their representatives’ birth numbers to business register. They can be fined if they fail to do it.

18 h