Parliament deadlocked

WITH the minority government unable to muster enough votes to start the parliamentary session after the summer recess, Slovakia is heading towards early elections.
The opposition has stubbornly blocked the opening of parliament since September 12. Some ruling parties say that early elections are the only way out.

It might look like business as usual, but the opposition's refusal to open parliament after summer recess has initiated a call for early elections
photo: SME - Funtál

WITH the minority government unable to muster enough votes to start the parliamentary session after the summer recess, Slovakia is heading towards early elections.

The opposition has stubbornly blocked the opening of parliament since September 12. Some ruling parties say that early elections are the only way out.

Hungarian Coalition Party (SMK) Chairman Béla Bugár announced on September 13 that his party would start working on draft legislation to shorten the current cabinet term.

"[Let's have] early elections as soon as possible. We will not be held hostage to the opposition or independent MPs [who refuse to initiate a parliamentary session]," Bugár told a press conference.

But Prime Minister Mikuláš Dzurinda would not give up the idea of completing the regular election term, which extends until fall of 2006.

At a press briefing held September 14, the PM said, "I am still a bit reserved on the issue of early elections."

The minority government will most likely target independent MPs in the upcoming talks in an attempt to gain their support. Unofficial sources suggest that the cabinet is well on its way to securing the needed 76 votes needed to initiate the start of the parliamentary session.

Dzurinda blamed the current obstruction by the opposition on Smer party leader Robert Fico.

"The current situation is because the Communists in parliament, headed by Robert Fico, used the fact that I decided to recall Pavol Rusko [from his position as economy minister] and that Rusko decided to take revenge," said the prime minister.

Rusko was dismissed from the cabinet on August 23 for an alleged conflict of interest involving a Sk104.5 million (€2.7 million) loan from a businessman active in the energy sector, for which Rusko was directly responsible.

Rusko, chairman of the New Citizen's Alliance (ANO), withdrew from the ruling coalition and joined the opposition together with three ANO MPs. The remaining nine ANO MPs splintered from the main ANO caucus and remained with the ruling coalition to support the Dzurinda cabinet. This splinter group, led by Ľubomír Lintner, was expelled from ANO.

According to the prime minister, Fico's misuse of the situation and Rusko's revenge "clearly damages Slovakia, evokes uncertainty in foreign investors and creates a picture of instability".

Soňa Szomolányi, political analyst with Bratislava's Comenius University, agreed that time was running short for Fico, a steady opponent of the right-wing government.

"Fico knows that the longer the ruling coalition lasts, the more visible the [positive] results of their work will be," she said.

According to Dzurinda, Fico's motivation is power and economic interest.

Szomolányi does not think early elections are the only solution.

"Early elections are still not for sure. There are still other ways. The SMK and Christian Democratic Movement (KDH) officials are creating pressure for it, especially on the independents. But they have a week for talks," Szomolányi told The Slovak Spectator.

Parliamentary speaker Pavol Hrušovský moved the start of parliamentary sessions from September 14 to September 20.

"Not all of those who have been blocking the start of parliament are Communists," he said, suggesting that some independent MPs could be talked into supporting the minority government.

Even if politicians agree that early elections should be held in Slovakia, the date of the elections would have to be tackled. Unlike the SMK or KDH, not all MPs agree that early elections should take place as soon as possible.

SMK's Bugár said that his party would not mind if early elections were held in March or April of next year.

"I think that some parties actually got scared [when they heard] that the elections could be so soon," Bugár told the press, adding that among these parties was the opposition Movement for a Democratic Slovakia (HZDS).

HZDS officials said that the best date for early elections would be June, which is just three months ahead of the planned regular election date.

Political analysts call the June date "advanced elections" rather than "early elections" because it is so soon before the end of the regular term anyway.

"Most parties would actually favour the advanced date of elections [rather than early elections]," said Grigorij Mesežnikov, political analyst with the Institute for Public Affairs, a think tank in Bratislava.

The exception is Smer. A stable leader in voter preference polls with a support of around 30 percent, Smer has no reason to hold the date of elections back.

However, in order to achieve early elections, MPs must approve a law shortening the current term. This law must be approved by a two-thirds constitutional majority of all MPs; that is, 90 out of 150 legislators must vote for it.

In the Slovak parliament, there are more than 20 independents who have little chance of re-election. In addition, opposition parties are still divided on the possible election term.

"To what extent the plans of the opposition [with early elections] are will show in the coming days," said Mesežnikov.

Unlike Szomolányi, however, Mesežnikov thinks that political talks will concentrate on the date of early, or advanced, elections rather than under what conditions the independents or the opposition would agree to keep the current cabinet in power until the end of the regular term.

"The demands of the opposition, the conditions in which they would back the minority cabinet, may be hard to meet. Smer wants privatization to be halted; HZDS wants the cabinet reconstructed with representatives of all parliamentary parties in it; it's complete nonsense," said Mesežnikov.

Analysts agreed that even if early or advanced elections were held, it would not be a tragedy.

"The Dzurinda cabinet is quite a success in terms of reforms. The economy is stable and going in a positive direction. [Early elections] would not be the end of the world," said Mesežnikov.

Szomolányi agreed. "Early elections are nothing unusual in democratic states. It is a legitimate political tool. Look at Germany, where [the chancellor Gerhard] Schröder himself asked for early elections to be held," she said.

PM Dzurinda maintains, however, that "my priorities are elsewhere than early elections".

Get daily Slovak news directly to your inbox

Top stories

The mass testing in Nitra.

News digest: Results from weekend nationwide testing still not out

The parliamentary committee recommends one candidate for new police chief. NASA picks a picture by Slovak photographer as its Astronomy Picture of the Day.

8 h
Gábor Grendel (OĽaNO), Juraj Šeliga (Za Ľudí), and SaS MPs Marian Viskupič and Jana Bittó Cigániková.

Matovič government takes after Smer in lawmaking

The second-largest testing scheme of the whole population is underway in Slovakia. Government says they ordered enough vaccines. Layoffs of transnationals in Bratislava.

13 h
PM Igor Matovič (front) and Economy Minister Richard Sulík (back)

Hlas is gaining strength, along with Sulík’s SaS

At the same time, most people think PM Matovič is not managing the coronavirus crisis well.

14 h
US President Joe Biden

Biden really is waking up each morning with the goal of making things better

The new president is old and imperfect, but it's difficult to question his motives.

24. jan