Spectator on facebook

Spectator on facebook

LACK OF CLEAR RULES ON SUPPORT FOR INVESTORS INTRODUCED COMPLICATIONS INTO FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT DEALS

Wild incentive era over, new rules ready

AN ERA of unrestricted wheeling and dealing between foreign investors and individual politicians comes to a close as Slovakia introduces clear rules regarding state-sponsored support for foreign investors.

Levice was ready to give a new home to Hankook, deal remains uncertain.
photo: TASR

AN ERA of unrestricted wheeling and dealing between foreign investors and individual politicians comes to a close as Slovakia introduces clear rules regarding state-sponsored support for foreign investors.

The lack of rules governing investment stimuli packages greatly complicated the Hankook Tire investment after former Economy Minister Pavol Rusko promised the Korean investor incentives that the cabinet refused to approve.

Hankook asked for state support worth 21.3 percent of its investment. After the cabinet refused to meet the tyremaker's demands, Hankook re-opened negotiations with Slovakia's neighbours.

Finance Minister Ivan Mikloš has been critical of Slovakia's inclination to attract foreign investors at any price and has long advocated establishing clear rules on incentives.

Mikloš believes that the country's failure to set guidelines has resulted in fewer foreign investments overall and thus created fewer jobs than what Slovakia could have achieved. And he said the country has used public funds to pay for investment incentives far more often than it would have if clear rules had existed.

Based on the new rules Slovakia would be divided into two zones. The green zone will mark poorer regions in urgent need of investments while the yellow zone will mark wealthy regions that have already absorbed a certain level of investments.

The Nitra, Banská Bystrica, Prešov and Košice regions, where unemployment exceeds 10 percent of the total number of working-age people, will be considered green. The Bratislava, Trnava, Trenčín and Žilina regions fall under the yellow zone.

The sectors of the economy will be divided to three parts. Sector A covers the processing industry and investment projects dealing with new production units and distribution and logistics centres. Strategic investments in the high-tech industry comprise Sector B, while Sector C covers research and development centres, including technological development centres.

The state will also evaluate the employment structure provided by the investor and base incentives on whether or not the investment can potentially attract additional investors. The government is eager to create the rules in such a way to encourage investments with higher added value.

The plan also introduces a ceiling for incentives in relationship to their total estimated value. Investments such as research and technology centres, determined to create the highest added value, will receive the largest volume of incentives.

Investment projects with the lowest added value, such as those in the processing industry, will receive the smallest volume of incentives.

The Council of Ministers with Economic Portfolio advised the cabinet to approve the rules on October 3.

Analysts agree that the lack of rules threatened the country's credibility in the eyes of investors. Admittedly, some saw it as a loophole to negotiate favourable conditions that they could not have received elsewhere.

Experts also say that an absence of rules automatically put some investors at a disadvantage while giving other, more powerful players an advantage.

"The lack of rules resulted in the state taking an uneven approach towards investors. It was difficult to guarantee that the state would be fair towards all," Miroslav Šmál, an analyst with Poštová banka, told The Slovak Spectator.

Above all, a lack of rules brought unnecessary delays to the process.

According to Šmál, the Slovak Investment and Trade Development Agency (SARIO) was crippled in its role as support agency, since without rules, it could not give investors a general idea of what the country could offer them.

"This situation resulted in the investors turning directly to the Economy Ministry and entering negotiations. Due to the lack of clear rules, the ministry obliged itself to things that the country could not fulfil, such as [purchasing land and building a highway] in the KIA investment. It became obvious that deadlines could not be met," Šmál said.

According to Minister Mikloš, concerning the KIA investment, the cabinet thought that Sk1.3 billion (€30 million) of state aid was needed to build infrastructure. After Pavol Rusko's dismissal, the cabinet learned that these expenditures would reach Sk2.9 billion (€80 million).

SARIO has been calling for clearer investment stimuli rules for some time.

"The agency needs to have clear rules on what incentives can be offered to which types of investors when submitting bids to investors," said the head of SARIO, Roman Kuruc, in an earlier interview with The Slovak Spectator.

Mikloš has previously said that SARIO has not known the volume of stimuli it should offer to investors.

According to Šmál, most countries have rules governing state assistance that help make up the country's national economic strategy.

"It is a basis for the state's approach towards investors, selecting certain investments and their evaluation not only from the point of view of profitability but also from the point of view of strategic importance for the country," Šmál concluded.

Top stories

How did Communism happen in Czechoslovakia?

For the 40 years, Czechs and Slovaks would celebrate February 25 as Victorious February, even though the enthusiasm of most of those who supported Communists in 1948 would very quickly evaporate.

Prime Minister Klement Gottwald (right) swears an oath into the hands of President Edvard Benes on February 27, 1948 at the Prague Castle.

Cemetery with a remarkable creative concept Photo

The shapes of tombstones were prescribed until 1997

Vrakuňa Cemetery in Bratislava

Being young is harder than it used to be

The failure of older generations to sympathise with youth means politics are primarily a contest of who can hand out more gifts to old people.

Young Slovaks have problems finding proper jobs.

Historian: After 1948, Czechoslovakia was paralysed with fear

On February 25, Czechs and Slovaks mark 70 years since the rise of Communism in their common state. Historian Jan Pešek talks about the coup and its aftermath.

Demonstration in Prague, Wenceslas' Square, on February 28, 1948.