Spectator on facebook

Spectator on facebook

INTERVIEW - VIDEO INCLUDED

Media might feel bullied into self-censorship

JUSTICE Minister Štefan Harabin has attracted public attention not only as the candidate most tipped to become head of the Slovak Supreme Court, but also for sending out-of-court settlement proposals to the publishers of the Sme, Pravda and Plus Jeden Deň dailies, and the Plus 7 Dní weekly. In his letters Harabin stated that they had published articles that had severely damaged his good reputation and honour and requested out-of-court settlements of €200,000 from each publisher to be sent to his account within 40 days in compensation for the non-pecuniary damages he alleges he has suffered. The cumulative sum requested from all periodicals is €600,000 (Plus Jeden Deň and Plus 7 Dní share the same publisher).

JUSTICE Minister Štefan Harabin has attracted public attention not only as the candidate most tipped to become head of the Slovak Supreme Court, but also for sending out-of-court settlement proposals to the publishers of the Sme, Pravda and Plus Jeden Deň dailies, and the Plus 7 Dní weekly. In his letters Harabin stated that they had published articles that had severely damaged his good reputation and honour and requested out-of-court settlements of €200,000 from each publisher to be sent to his account within 40 days in compensation for the non-pecuniary damages he alleges he has suffered. The cumulative sum requested from all periodicals is €600,000 (Plus Jeden Deň and Plus 7 Dní share the same publisher).

The Slovak Spectator spoke to Colin Peters, press freedom adviser for Europe and the Americas with the International Press Institute (IPI), about Harabin’s attempts to obtain damages.

The Slovak Spectator (TSS): Is it a standard procedure on the part of a political representative to demand such high sums in a proposed out-of-court settlement?

Colin Peters (CP): As such agreements are often undisclosed, it’s not possible to say whether this is standard procedure or not. However, we certainly do not condone such action, particularly by such a high-ranking politician, and particularly when there were other forms of redress available to him.

It's disappointing that an individual who, in a manner of speaking, “represents” justice in Slovakia, has bypassed all other forms of redress laid out in the law and taken recourse instead to demanding large sums of cash.

TSS: What impact might such a proposal have on the media in Slovakia, especially during a period when publishers are suffering from economic pressures due to the global downturn?

CP: The obvious threat is that of forcing media into insolvency - particularly if the periodicals threatened buckle to Harabin’s demand, thus setting a precedent for others who might seek to enrich themselves in such a way.

TSS: Several state officials have been targeting the Slovak press through civil defamation lawsuits. In your opinion, what impact does such a tendency have on the media environment?

CP: Apart from the financial impact, crucial in an economic climate such as the one we are experiencing, the media may feel bullied into practising self-censorship to avoid influential politicians demanding large sums of money.

If Harabin is genuinely seeking redress for what he feels is damage done to his reputation, we feel he is taking the wrong approach. He is, in my opinion, holding the newspapers to ransom, with the threat of lengthy court procedures and the possibility of exaggerated damages should they fail to pay up.

Harabin's actions typify one of the main concerns to come out of IPI’s recent fact-finding mission to Bratislava, namely that some Slovak judges are demanding disproportionate damages in civil actions, and that the judiciary itself is not acting in an independent manner. We would urge Harabin to retract this demand.


Top stories

PM Fico wants Education Minister’s resignation

Education Minister Peter Plavčan has refused to leave, the Prime Minister demanding his resignation.

Education Minister Peter Plavčan

Things that make us different also make us stronger

On August 19, a rainbow flag will fly over the US Embassy in Bratislava to represent the firm commitment of the United States to defending the human rights of LGBTI people, writes Ambassador Sterling.

The rainbow flag flew over the US Embassy in Bratislava in 2016.

Southern Slovakia will face heat again

The first-level warning is issued for the 16th and 17th.

Interior minister will not be prosecuted for corruption

The prosecutor’s office does not find his business with tax fraud suspect suspicious.

Interior Minister Robert Kaliňák