Minority report

Dividing people into “Us” and “Them” is now a typical feature of most of Prime Minister Robert Fico’s statements about migrants, refugees, foreigners, Muslims, and so forth.

Moldava nad BodvouMoldava nad Bodvou(Source: Tibor Somogyi)

“SINCE the very beginning I have had the impression that the investigation wouldn’t be just,”says Igor, a man from the Budulovská settlement in Moldava nad Bodvou who was recently featured in an Al Jazeera documentary about the police probe in the raid that left him and dozens of others from his village brutally beaten.

The results of the investigation have not been fully revealed, but it is clear from the documents that The Slovak Spectator obtained recently that no transgressions were found on the part of the police in four of the six points of the motion, including abuse of powers of a public official and the crime of torture.

Read also:Investigation found no torture in infamous police raidRead more 

Though such investigations and their results cannot be evaluated based on emotion, there is more than that to suggest that the conclusion not to punish or reproach anyone for what happened three years ago in Moldava’s Roma settlement is highly questionable.

Ombudswoman Jana Dubovcová has repeatedly criticised the conduct of the police during the raid and went so far as to lead an open conflict with the interior minister over the incident. But she was not alone. International organisations, including the Regional Office of the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights and the European Roma Rights Centre (ERRC) point out that the prosecution started six months after the raid took place and then it took another year and half to complete.

“If police authorities really would like to stop police atrocities they would act swiftly, professionally, and very fast to find those who are responsible and sanction them,” ERRC Executive Director András Ujlaky said.

At this point it is still not clear if the whole case will end up closed with the conclusion that there were no mistakes. If that turns out to be the case, it will be just the latest episode that confirms the seemingly never ending discrimination against the Roma minority.

Unfortunately, in Slovakia today, hardly anyone will raise their eyebrows over this. In the past people were not sensitive enough to discrimination, but things have gotten much worse in recent months.

Hostility towards minorities, towards otherness, is now on the rise due to the wave of migrants flowing to Europe – although not to Slovakia – and the way the government has framed the whole issue.

Dividing people into “Us” and “Them” is now a typical feature of most of Prime Minister Robert Fico’s statements about migrants, refugees, foreigners, Muslims, and so forth. He explicitly says that “our” security is more important than “their” rights.

Such statements allow discrimination or even open racism to be tolerated. Such statements inherently prepare the ground for any future divisions to be excused easily, or, worse still, to go unnoticed. Some analysts say that the ruling Smer has employed the rhetoric of extremists. “Not even Le Pen would say such a thing,” Anne Dastakian, a French reporter of the leftist daily Liberation, said in an interview for the Sme daily when she heard Fico linking the refugee crisis with terrorist attacks.

Smer employed such rhetoric in order to strengthen its campaign message “We protect Slovakia”, and now statements that decent politicians should never utter are mainstream. In other words, they are becoming a normal, everyday form of communication that does not disturb anyone – if it ever did.

Sadly, Smer has little or no motivation to change this, since the strategy seems to be working. Its preferences among voters are close to 40 percent. As long as that is the case, it is easy to predict who will have the upper hand in Moldava-style controversies.

Get daily Slovak news directly to your inbox

The processing of personal data is subject to our Privacy Policy and the Cookie Policy. Before submitting your e-mail address, please make sure to acquaint yourself with these documents.

Top stories

Kuciak’s boss: I'm 100 percent sure Kočner ordered the murder

Kuciak was not doing it for money but for a higher principle, said editor-in-chief of Aktuality.sk.

Ján Kuciak's colleagues

National court drama intensifies as polls raise alarm

The first week of the Kuciak murder trial saw key witnesses take the stand while polls do not rule out a far-right victory in February.

Peter Toth

Haščák said the message he got from Kočner was not about Kuciak

Two people have already been punished in the murder case.

Penta financial group partner Jaroslav Haščák was called forward to the court because of a message Kočner had sent to him prior to the Kuciak murder

President Čaputová: The path of hatred leads to tragedies and crimes

The president and the prime minister commemorated the inhabitants of Ostrý Grúň and Kľak killed during WWII.

The commemorative event in the village of Kľak.