Spectator on facebook

Spectator on facebook

Court awards €17,000 in compensation for unlawful sterilisation

After more than 10 years the case is not over as the verdict is not yet effective.

Court, illustrative stock photo(Source: SITA )

The Košice II District Court ruled that the rights of a Roma woman, who was sterilised at the Košice-based Louis Pasteur University Hospital in 1999 without her informed consent, were violated. The court obligated the hospital to apologise and pay financial compensation of almost €17,000 to the woman. However, the verdict in the part pertaining to payment of the compensation dating to February 19 is not yet valid, as the hospital filed an appeal, the NGO Consultancy for Civic and Human Rights informed on April 25.

The woman was sterilised in 1999 during a premature Cesarean section birth of her second child when she was 24 years old.

“She was informed that sterilisation was to be performed by the doctor only when in labour and during strong contractions, when she feared for the life of her as-of-yet unborn child,” the NGO Consultancy for Civic and Human Rights informed. “The next day she was told she had been sterilised without receiving any further information about the operation or its consequences. Later she found out that a written sterilisation application, dated from the day of the birth of the child, signed in her hand, was included in her medical records – as if it was she who initiated the procedure.”

The woman turned to courts in 2005, complaining that the sterilisation was performed without her informed consent and no adequate time was granted for considering such a serious interference with her reproductive rights. She pursued an apology and compensation of approximately €16,600 (Sk500,000).

Initially general courts turned down her complaint, but the Constitutional Court ruled in 2009 that the courts by their decisions violated her constitutional right for a fair lawsuit and returned the case to the district court for further proceeding. This court issued in 2011 a verdict saying that rights of the woman were violated and granted her compensation of €1,500. Two years later the regional court cancelled the verdict due to the amount of compensation being too low.

The hospital argued that the sterilisation was performed during labour as a life-saving procedure. The district court, in line with recent verdicts of the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, confirmed that sterilisation is never a life-saving procedure, and that a physician cannot conduct it without informed consent.  

“I’m pleased to see this injustice redressed after more than 10 years,” said the woman, who received legal representation from Consultancy for Civic and Human Rights. “Even though no money in the world can bring back my health and take away the hurt, it’s important in my view for women like me to pursue justice. Therefore, I’d like to encourage other Roma women not to be afraid and fight back when their rights are trampled on.” 

Top stories

Marking Maria Theresa Photo

Exhibitions, conferences, coronation festivities and more.

Schloss Hof holds the Alliances and Enmities exhibition.

‘Government seems to control parliament, not vice versa’

Jana Dubovcová talks about her performance as ombudswoman, and the topics that remain for her successor.

Jana Dubovcová leaves the ombudswoman post after five years.

Hostages to fortune

Britain will trigger Article 50 to leave the EU on 29 March. She and her EU partners could, and should, guarantee the rights of their citizens living abroad. That they have not is a disgrace.

Theresa May announced Brexit will start on March 29.

Actor to politicians: You are playing a terrible theatre

One of the main characters in the movie Únos, about Slovak politicians and the mafia in the 90’s has a message for politicians.

Maroš Kramár