Spectator on facebook

Spectator on facebook

Court: Slovak government put private health insurers at a disadvantage

The Court of Justice of the European Union issued a ruling concerning the alleged unjustified help to state-run insurance company.

Dôvera health insurer(Source: Sme - Ján Krošlák)

The only state-run health insurer in Slovakia, Všeobecná Zdravotná Poisťovňa (VšZP), is an enterprise, so the European Union rules on state aid applying to it. This stems from a ruling issued by the Court of Justice of the European Union in Luxembourg. It also states that all health insurance companies should have the same conditions for doing business, the Hospodárske Noviny economic daily wrote on February 6.

The judges in Luxembourg were dealing with a complaint submitted by private health insurer Dôvera, which claimed that the Slovak authorities unjustifiably helped its rivals, state-run insurers VšZP and the now-defunct Spoločná Zdravotná Poisťovňa (SZP). The state helped the latter with €15 million, and it prevented its bankruptcy only by merging with the former.

Read also: Read also:Slovakia wins another dispute with Dôvera health insurer

Dôvera, owned by the Penta financial group, first turned to the European Commission, but the EC turned down the complaint in 2014, stating that the help to the state-run insurer was not state aid.

The current ruling of the Luxembourg-based court annuls the original EC decision. It has not said, however, whether the help was really state aid, the daily summed up.

ECJ: All health insurers should have the same conditions

The ruling of the court states that all health insurance companies should have the same conditions for doing business, Dôvera PR manager Branislav Cehlárik told the TASR newswire.

Moreover, Dôvera insists that the losses incurred by SZP and VšZP should not be paid for by all taxpayers. Its management now assumes that the matter will now return to the European Commission.

Read also: Read also:Health Insurer Dôvera files court suit over administrative fine

“We believe that the EC will reassess its original position,” said Dôvera CEO Martin Kultan, as quoted by TASR.

The motion was originally filed with the EC by Dôvera, which was later joined by Union ZP. They complained about total unjustified assistance amounting to €170 million in total, TASR wrote. This allegedly took the form of increasing SZP’s share capital by €15 million, repaying SZP’s debt via a state-owned company called Veriteľ (Creditor), a subsidy from the Health Ministry, and increasing VšZP’s share capital by €65.1 million in 2010.

Disclaimer: Dôvera is owned by the Penta financial group which has a minority share in Petit Press, the co-owner of The Slovak Spectator.

Topic: Health care


Top stories

Istanbul ratification still nowhere in sight

The international document preventing violence against women was one of the reasons why a former justice minister left the government.

Students will return to streets on Friday

They will hold up the letters of the last sentence from the last story by murdered Slovak journalist Ján Kuciak.

The April 15 protest in Bratislava

How a furniture hit is produced: IKEA’s Billy is from Slovakia Photo

The plant in Trnava has been operating since 1993, daily exporting furniture to the whole world.

Popular Billy bookshelves by IKEA ar emad ein Slovakia