Five years after the Moldava raid, the victims have turned into perpetrators

June 19 marks the fifth anniversary of the brutal and much-discussed raid in the Roma settlement; and it points to five of those beaten being charged with perjury.

Moldava nad BodvouMoldava nad Bodvou (Source: Tibor Somogyi)

The infamous police raid on Budulovská Street of the Roma settlement in Moldava and Bodvou took place on June 19, 2013. Since then, police have been found not guilty of any wrongdoing – but the situation took an even more surprising twist.

SkryťTurn off ads
Article continues after video advertisement
SkryťTurn off ads
Article continues after video advertisement

The coalition of non-governmental organisations (Equity, o.z., ERRC – European Roma Rights’ Centre, ETP Slovensko, Amnesty International Slovensko, CVEK) claim that the investigation of the raid was not consequent and detailed, not to mention independent, the SITA newswire reported. On the 5th anniversary, they point out that until now, no police officers have been made responsible. On the contrary, the beaten Roma have been charged, Ján Glovičko informed for the coalition of NGOs.

SkryťTurn off ads
Read also: UN condemns Moldava raid Read more 

They do not agree with the findings of the investigation of the Interior Ministry, nor with the charge concerning six Roma for perjury – as they recognised the officers who beat them during the raid.

Police, judiciary missteps

NGOs also protested against the steps of the Košice I District Court which ruled, without a main trial and through a criminal order, that two of the six charged Roma are guilty. The activists point to the violation of the principle of consistency, since the first steps of the investigation steps were taken seven months after the raid; and the principle of independence, since the Interior Ministry inspection is not an independent investigation body, and the rule that a police officer cannot investigate his/her colleague must be observed, according to SITA.

SkryťTurn off ads
Read also: Kaliňák speaks out on Moldava raid Read more 

“The court’s proceeding seems to be inadequately prompt in this case,” Jarmila Lajčáková of the Centre for Research of Ethnicity and Culture (CVEK) pointed out for SITA. “The Prosecutor’s Office delivered the charge to court on May 30; while the single judge sentenced them the next day, May 31, 2018, through a criminal order, without any possibility of coming to court and defending themselves.”

The pro bono lawyer active in this case, Roman Kvasnica, is of the same opinion. He adds that the clients are innocent since the course of events they testified to in connection to the police raid was a description of what they had experienced.

“It is obvious that in particular their right to defence and a fair trial has been violated,” Kvasnica sums up.

NGOs publish their demands

The coalition of NGOs thus put together requests aimed at the state bodies, asking that the prosecution of beaten Roma be stopped, an independent investigation body be established, as well as addressing the top representatives of the armed forces not to use stigmatising language that worsen prejudices and not to violate the principle of equal treatment, Kamila Gunišová of Amnesty International Slovensko told SITA.

Read also: Fico defends police in Moldava nad Bodvou Read more 

The NGOs have prepared a website,, which includes the full chronology of the case, including statements of the public officials who politicised the investigation, as well as the demands of the NGO's. Updated information on the case will be published on the website as well..

Leonard Horváth, one of the dozens of Roma from Moldava nad Bodvou beaten by the police officers during the controversial June 2013 raid, now lives in Germany.

Police, ministry see things differently

The Police Corps President Milan Lučanský claims that the Roma beat themselves, and both the Interior Ministry and the Constitutional Court back the officers. On the other hand, the incident has been criticised by then-ombudswoman Jana Dubovcová and former government proxy for Roma communities Peter Pollák, the Denník N daily writes.

Horváth is one of six beaten Roma who have been accused of perjury. A man and a woman have already been sentenced, with one receiving one year conditionally with 15-month probation. The woman has not been sentenced to a combined sentence, due to her previous sentences and punishments, the Košice Korzár daily explained.

Read also: General Prosecutor’s Office becomes involved in Moldava raid case Read more 

Four other men are still awaiting trial. They are accused of falsely declaring that the police officers beat them.

The case very much resembles the infamous case of Hedviga Malinová, Lýdia Šuchová of the Equity NGO noted, as quoted by Korzár.

Top stories


News digest: The neverending story of an unfinished Bratislava Hospital

Zvolen to have a school inspired by one in Florida, rock band Billy Talent returns, and why it was better to be considered a prostitute than lesbian.

9 h
Vrakuňa’s citizens presented apples washed in water with leaked toxins at the protest in 2016.

Chemical time bomb in Bratislava’s Vrakuňa keeps ticking

The state is failing to solve leaking chemical waste dump.

31. may
Jupiter (centre) and its Galilean moons: from left Ganymede, Io, Europa and Callisto. Juice with deployed antennas and arrays is in the bottom right.

From Košice to Ganymede: Slovak engineers are leaving their mark in space

Slovaks are active participants in two ongoing space missions.

20. may
SkryťClose ad