Journalists can write freely about the Gorilla file

The Penta financial group has failed with its lawsuit at the Constitutional Court.

Penta residence in the Digital Park, BratislavaPenta residence in the Digital Park, Bratislava(Source: Sme)

Media can refer to, cite, and write freely about the infamous Gorilla file, describing the non-standard relations between high-ranking politicians and businesses, the Constitutional Court ruled.

It scrutinised the lawsuit submitted by the Penta financial group against the Hospodárske Noviny daily, which used a citation from the file in one of its opinion pieces, the Denník N daily reported.

The court issued its statement, written by the senate composed of Lajos Mészáros, Jana Laššáová and Sergej Kohut, on February 6.

Read also:What were the links between Kočner and Penta? Read more 

“The existence of transcripts of the Gorilla file is unchallenged (the question of authenticity is a different matter),” reads the ruling, as quoted by the Sme daily. “The reference of a journalist to the Gorilla file, regardless of the authenticity being confirmed or not, thus provides a sufficient factual basis for the contested statements, the object of which is the assessment/analysis of the content of the file or conclusions drawn from it.”

The Gorilla file describes the alleged meetings between Jaroslav Haščák of Penta with various politicians in a flat on Vazovova Street in Bratislava between the years 2005 and 2006. They allegedly discussed or even took bribes, Sme wrote.

Penta and politicians have been challenging the contents of the file. The recordings found in the safe of controversial businessman Marian Kočner could prove its authenticity, according to the daily.

Read also:Penta wants investigators to destroy Gorilla recordings Read more 

At the same time, the Constitutional Court has criticised the lower instance courts for demanding journalists to check the document’s authenticity.

“It is absurd to require journalists to replace law enforcement bodies in any way,” the ruling reads, as quoted by Sme. This would mean that journalists would not be able to cite from the file, which is “unacceptable in regards to freedom of speech protection”.

Disclaimer: The Penta financial group has a minority share in Petit Press, the co-owner of The Slovak Spectator.

Get daily Slovak news directly to your inbox

The processing of personal data is subject to our Privacy Policy and the Cookie Policy. Before submitting your e-mail address, please make sure to acquaint yourself with these documents.

Top stories

Kuciak’s boss: I'm 100 percent sure Kočner ordered the murder

Kuciak was not doing it for money but for a higher principle, said editor-in-chief of Aktuality.sk.

Ján Kuciak's colleagues

National court drama intensifies as polls raise alarm

The first week of the Kuciak murder trial saw key witnesses take the stand while polls do not rule out a far-right victory in February.

Peter Toth

Haščák said the message he got from Kočner was not about Kuciak

Two people have already been punished in the murder case.

Penta financial group partner Jaroslav Haščák was called forward to the court because of a message Kočner had sent to him prior to the Kuciak murder

President Čaputová: The path of hatred leads to tragedies and crimes

The president and the prime minister commemorated the inhabitants of Ostrý Grúň and Kľak killed during WWII.

The commemorative event in the village of Kľak.