How beaten Roma became suspected criminals

The European Court for Human Rights recently ruled in favour of two of the Roma injured in the Moldava raid seven years ago. This is how the case unfolded over time.

Budulovská settlement of Moldava nad BodvouBudulovská settlement of Moldava nad Bodvou (Source: Sme - Ján Krošlák)

Róbert Rybár was dragged out of his house. He remembers receiving five or six kicks in his ribs, and several punches to the head. That is how he has repeatedly described the treatment he received from police officers during the June 2013 police raid that Slovakia has since come to know as the Moldava Raid.

Even though several people were left injured after the raid, the investigation did not find any violation of the rules of police actions.

On the pretext of searching for seven men for whom they had arrest warrants, 63 police officers raided the settlement called Budulovská in the eastern-Slovak town of Moldava nad Bodvou on June 19, 2013. They found none of those men, but violence ensued. Several persons were injured and 15 Roma were taken to the police station.

Two weeks later, then Police Corps president Tibor Gašpar backed the local police officers and stated that the Roma had been treating the police with more respect since the raid. Budulovská locals did not agree with his assessment.

“It was all unnecessary violence,” Rybár told the press. “We didn't do anything. On the day of the police raid they came to us, they entered our houses without permission and they started beating us head-on.”

Charges were brought against some of the police officers, but they were all dismissed. On the other hand, Rybár and five more of the beaten Roma were later accused of false testimony against the police officers. Eastern-Slovak courts have been dealing with their cases.

On September 1, 2020, Rybár and his neighbour from Budulovská, Roland Dančo, won their case against the Slovak Republic in the European Court for Human Rights (ECHR). The court upheld the view of the plaintiffs that they suffered inhuman treatment and that the authorities failed to conduct a proper investigation into that ill-treatment. The court awarded €20,000 to each of the two men as non-pecuniary damage, and €6,500 jointly in respect of costs and expenses.

Some see the ECHR ruling as a game-changer in the case. Unless Slovakia learns from the ruling, police brutality will occur again, stated former police investigator Jozef Šátek.

“The ruling talks about the entire politics-police-prosecutor system, which organised, carried out and approved the brutal police raid, then intentionally slowed the investigation of it, and finally manipulated the investigation results to such an extent that it aimed the blade of criminal law against the victims, accused them and charged them,” Šátek wrote on his Facebook page.

Another ruling still expected

The rest of this article is premium content at Spectator.sk
Subscribe now for full access

I already have subscription - Sign in

Subscription provides you with:
  • Immediate access to all locked articles (premium content) on Spectator.sk
  • Special weekly news summary + an audio recording with a weekly news summary to listen to at your convenience (received on a weekly basis directly to your e-mail)
  • PDF version of the latest issue of our newspaper, The Slovak Spectator, emailed directly to you
  • Access to all premium content on Sme.sk and Korzar.sk

Get daily Slovak news directly to your inbox

Theme: Igor Matovič

Read more articles by the topic
This article is also related to other trending topics
Roma community, Robert Kaliňák

Top stories

News digest: Some schools open, so do some ski resorts

Top prosecutor to be appointed soon. Zsuzsová goes to prison in a murder case. Pezinok judges are busy deciding about custodies for high-profile suspects.

Some schools will open on December 7

Matovič pushed through testing at schools, government is launching a pilot project this weekend.

PM Igor Matovič (front) and Education Minister Branislav Gröhling  (back)

Freed in the Kuciak murder case, guilty of another murder

The Specialised Criminal Court sends Alena Zsuzsová to prison for ordering the murder of former Hurbanovo mayor. She appealed against the verdict, insists she is innocent.

Alena Zsuzsová is escorted to the courtroom.

Health Ministry gearing up for COVID vaccines

Mass campaign planned to get people to take jab.

Illustrative stock photo