New rules for police chief election are a disappointment

The amendment to the law governing the Police Presidium gives it a slight face-lift but experts see it as a huge disappointment.

L-R INterior Minister Denisa Saková and Police President Milan LučanskýL-R INterior Minister Denisa Saková and Police President Milan Lučanský(Source: Sme - Jozef Jakubčo)

Thousands of people who protested in the streets under the For a Decent Slovakia initiative asked, among other things, for an independent police head and for the separation of the Police Inspectorate from the Interior Ministry. The solution tabled by the new Interior Minister, Denisa Saková of the ruling Smer party – who replaced Robert Kaliňák – is however deemed harmful by experts.

Compared to the original version, the recent changes proposed in the draft amendment are less fundamental. The Police President will not be selected directly by the Interior Minister but in the first round they would be evaluated by a jury of seven appointed by the Minister, the General Prosecutor, the previous Police Chief and the rector of the Police Academy. In the second round, the Parliamentary Committee for Defence and Security, in which the coalition parties currently have a majority, would choose. Lawyer Kristína Babiaková of the Via Iuris civic association points out that this means the selection would have a more balanced composition. However she goes on to explain that “Whether this concerns labour unions, the rector of the Police Academy or others – all these people are connected to the Police Corps, and thus also to the Interior Minister.”

For example, the rector of the Police Academy is chosen directly by the Minister. He or she also cooperates closely with other officials who are supposed to select the committee members. Minister Saková refused to give in to the initiative proposed by the civic organisation We Want to Believe.

“The very existence of the committee is a step forward by the Minister but she failed to bring specific arguments as to why she had refused the proposal to make the committee’s composition well-balanced,” Babiaková says.

The Interior Ministry has only agreed to stricter criteria for selecting the people who can sit on the committee. They should have ethical and professional qualities and the General Prosecutor cannot appoint a police officer to the committee.

Lučanský will not be allowed to stay

Even though Saková’s amendment does not involve a potential recall of the Police President, she failed to detail the reasons for such a step. The draft would also have to be passed by three-fifths of the defence-security committee and the former Police President Tibor Gašpar would very probably have been supported by the committee, for example. Chair of the committee, Anton Hrnko of the junior coalition party SNS, said after Gašpar’s voluntary resignation that he is not happy about this end result.

Inspection will not be separate

The rest of this article is premium content at Spectator.sk
Subscribe now for full access

I already have subscription - Sign in

Subscription provides you with:
  • Immediate access to all locked articles (premium content) on Spectator.sk
  • Special weekly news summary + an audio recording with a weekly news summary to listen to at your convenience (received on a weekly basis directly to your e-mail)
  • PDF version of the latest issue of our newspaper, The Slovak Spectator, emailed directly to you
  • Access to all premium content on Sme.sk and Korzar.sk

The processing of personal data is subject to our Privacy Policy and the Cookie Policy. Before submitting your e-mail address, please make sure to acquaint yourself with these documents.

Top stories

Six people involved in the surveillance of journalists, Kočner paid thousands

People who followed journalists for Kočner are trying to rid themselves of guilt.

Peter Tóth

Trump will meet Pellegrini at the White House

The two politicians will discuss defence and economic cooperation this May.

The White House

After historical sights in Slovakia have burned, is there better fire protection?

Kunerad Castle in the Žilina Region has burned down twice in eight years, and Krásna Hôrka is still undergoing construction seven years after burning.

Krásna Hôrka Castle caught fire in March 2012.

Taxpayers still pay for former PM Fico's bodyguards

The Interior Ministry refuses to say why or reveal how much Fico's security costs.

Smer head Robert Fico.