Visegrad Group’s labour ministers criticise new child benefits in Austria

They have turned to the European Commission to decide on the matter.

V4 labour ministers signed a letter for European Commissioner Employment, Social Affairs, Skills and Labor Mobility Marianne Thyssen.V4 labour ministers signed a letter for European Commissioner Employment, Social Affairs, Skills and Labor Mobility Marianne Thyssen. (Source: TASR)

The ministers of labour and social affairs of the Visegrad Group (V4) countries, i.e. Slovakia, the Czech Republic, Poland and Hungary, have objected to the changes to child benefits adopted by the Austrian parliament. These in fact cut the sum granted to foreigners working in Austria, whose children live in another country.

In their opinion, the law is at odds with the European Union’s legislation and the principle of equal treatment. Thus the ministers signed a common statement and turned to the European Commissioner for Employment, Social Affairs, Skills and Labor Mobility Marianne Thyssen, asking her to scrutinise the changes.

“We ask the European Commission to act,” said Slovak Labour Minister Ján Richter, as quoted by the SITA newswire.

Apart from the V4 ministers, their colleagues from the labour and social affairs ministries in Slovenia, Lithuania and Bulgaria have also joined the protest, he added.

Negative impact on families and mobility expected

The new Austrian law, expected to become effective on January 1, 2019, will have a strong impact on the families of V4 citizens.

“It is expected that after the law comes into force, the socio-economic status of 87,500 children living in V4 countries will be negatively affected,” said Richter, as quoted by SITA.

He is convinced that all workers should receive the same benefits for paying the same taxes and payroll levies.

The signatories also agreed that the indexation of child benefits will negatively impact the situation of mobile workers and will distract them from free movement. It will also widen the gap in the EU.

“This indexation is undignified and denies the principle of equal treatment,” said State Secretary for the Czech Labour Ministry Petr Hůrka, as quoted by the TASR newswire.

What will happen now?

Richter expects that there will be two phases of solutions now. First, that the EC will start acting based on the letter. Second, that it will turn to the courts. This phase will start after three months.

“We expect that the EC will turn to the European Court since we don’t expect there to be an agreement,” Richter said, as quoted by TASR.

At the same time, the V4 ministers agreed that the best solution to the current situation will be to act in concert. They will not submit individual motions to the European court, Richter added, as reported by SITA.

Get daily Slovak news directly to your inbox

Top stories

News digest: Foreigners’ Police departments remain closed

Slovenia has ordered PCR tests developed by Slovak scientists. Holocaust survivors received the coronavirus vaccine jab.

12 h

Slovakia has more and more vaccines available. State lacks courage

Slovakia is taking a cautious approach to make sure it will be able to deliver second doses when needed.

16 h
Police control at the border crossing in Drietomá (Trenčín Region).

Stricter curfew rules come into force, police intensify checks

Negative test result required when going to work or doing sports in nature.

18 h
The entry of new data is required via

Companies complain about an absurd fee. They need to add information state also has

Firms have to add their representatives’ birth numbers to business register. They can be fined if they fail to do it.

18 h