The Education Ministry has allocated stimuli against the law

Several companies, which obtained R&D subsidies, are unregistered and do not do research.

Education Minister Martina LubyováEducation Minister Martina Lubyová (Source: SME)

The Education Ministry has recently allocated some stimuli on research and development, amounting to €33 million, to 30 firms unlawfully, the Sme daily reported.

Seven companies were not entitled to receive any stimuli from the state budget since they are not listed in the register of public sector partners, as stems from the law. Being listed in the register is a requirement to receive financial support, said the lawyers approached by Sme.

Three companies owned by businessman Martin Babiar from Michalovce (Košice Region) have received the state subsidy as well. In the past, Babiar worked alongside Slovak National Party (SNS) chair Andrej Danko at the SBS Dynasty firm, Sme reported.

Moreover, some of the companies have never carried out any research.

Education Minister Martina Lubyová (SNS nominee) has pledged to publish the names of the people who assessed the projects, by mid-January, Sme wrote.

Companies were asked to submit their applications for subsidies in mid-September and, after approval, received the money in late 2018.

No exception

Some companies, which received the support of €409,000-€1,334,000 from the ministry, have not been listed in the register of public sector partners.

"The ministry did not inform us beforehand about the obligation to be registered," said Bruno Goban of the company Biomedical Engineering, which also obtained the subsidy, Sme quoted.

Read also:Education Ministry fails to distribute €100 million for research this year Read more 

The Education Ministry has claimed it followed the law on stimuli for research and development, which does not require a firm to be registered if asking for this kind of support, not subsidies.

Andrej Leontiev of the law firm Taylor Wessing, one of the authors of the law on the register of public sector partners, does not agree, calling the ministry's explanation wrong. No exception that would allow a firm not to be registered exists, he told Sme.

"In this case, the firms are without a doubt public sector partners, which have to be listed in the register while the time contracts are valid," said lawyer Martin Černák, as quoted by Sme.

Meanwhile, Justice Minister Gábor Gál (Most-Híd) plans to ask for and scrutinise the legal analysis, based on which the Education Ministry signed the agreement with seven companies. The information the ministry currently has suggest that the agreements could have been signed at odds with the law. In this case, the state can terminate the agreement and ask for a refund of the subsidy, Sme reported.

Moreover, the Education Ministry might have committed a minor offence and be fined with up to €100,000 per agreement, which means that the ministry might face a fine of €700,000. However, the Supreme Audit Authority (NKÚ) is not planning any inspection at the Education Ministry for now, Sme wrote.

Stimuli do not come from EU funds

"In the case of the five firms, we did not manage to find any information on whether they did research," said Freedom and Solidarity (SaS) MP Branislav Gröhling, as quoted by Sme, adding that some firms operate in completely different areas, not R&D.

Read also:What is the Plavčan scandal all about? Read more 

The ministry claimed the R&D stimuli are also supposed to support new companies and startups, which cannot prove their activities in research yet.

Although this ministry's scandal resembles the one from the summer of 2017, when the Education Ministry also allocated money for R&D to companies that had never performed any research, there is one difference, Sme wrote.

The subsidies came from the EU in 2017. This time, the stimuli have been appropriated from the state budget.

SaS also called on PM Peter Pellegrini (Smer) to adopt a clear attitude on the scandal. The Government's Office responded that the prime minister will discuss the subsidies with Lubyová at the January 9 governmental session, the TASR newswire reported.

Get daily Slovak news directly to your inbox

Top stories

How a Catholic charity became a voice for migrants in Slovakia

Religious organisations have added leverage in changing perceptions of foreigners and migrants, says Caritas Slovakia.

Caritas Slovakia's ‘World Without “the Other” – Migration Myths’ campaign educates Slovaks on migration in a fun and artistic way.

Secret votes and public lies

There are uncanny echoes today of Slovakia’s agonies over its choice of chief prosecutor ten years ago.

Dobroslav Trnka (left) and Jozef Čentéš (right), the candidate who was eventually selected by MPs in 2011, never got to take up the post because the then president, Ivan Gašparovič refused to appoint him for reasons that were never clearly explained.

News digest: Slovakia to spend three Advent weekends with testing. President wants it to be voluntary

Seven candidates for the general prosecutor post approved. Acting general prosecutor steps down.

Installation of Christmas tree in Trnava

Which are the largest law firms in Slovakia?

For the first time, the ranking also provides an overview in partial categories of law.