Slovakia is not a mafia state yet, but it is in danger

Viktor Orbán critic says mafia states are particularly contagious in post-Communist countries.

Balint MagyarBalint Magyar (Source: Courtesy of B.M.)

SME/The Slovak Spectator (SME/TSS): How can a democratic state turn into a criminal gang?

Bálint Magyar (BM): A mafia state emerges when no longer oligarchs or representatives of the underworld but the government operates like a criminal organization. This could be called the organised criminal upperworld, with all due consequences. It is a privatised form of a parasite state. An adopted political family organised around the chief patron becomes the ruling elite. That one person, the Godfather in Hungary, is Viktor Orbán.

SME/TSS: At what point did you realise that something went wrong in Hungary?

BM: After 2010 the state gradually limited free competition. Between 2009 and 2015 the ratio of public procurements assigned without public notice increased from 20 to over 60 percent of all orders. They have also increased the financial limit for procurements that do not require a public tender, and thus widened the space for non-transparent offers. Further, due to what they declare national-economic or security interests they can fully avoid public tenders in all cases they think serves their interest. As a result, orders have become radically overpriced. In a country where actors of the public procurement process are autonomous players, there is a limit for overpricing: I can ask 10 or 20 percent more, but I cannot ask double the amount of the estimated price of the project. Because if I won with such an offer, other bidders can turn to court. Once a mafia state gets hold of procurement, there is no end to overpricing. That is why the price for one seat in newly-built stadiums in Hungary is higher than anywhere in western Europe.

SME/TSS: To what extent are voters aware of such abuse of public resources?

BM: Most international corruption perception surveys ask entrepreneurs whether they needed to bribe anyone to get a state order. But that question concerns corruption in a competitive market. In a mafia state, there is no corruption concerning "free competition", because entrepreneurs don’t even get into a situation where they would have the possibility of bribing anyone. Orders are controlled from above, and distributed in the early stages if the process. In the survey of the Medián Public Opinion and Market Research Institute - conducted in December 2017 - people were asked if they believed the abuse of public finances is the result of the occasional private deeds of public servants, or if corruption is centrally and systematically organised from above. Even as many as 33 percent of Fidesz voters said that they are state-controlled deeds. Obviously, the portion of people with that opinion is much higher among voters of the opposition leftwing and liberal parties (74 percent) and voters of the extreme right opposition party Jobbik (84 percent).

This is no longer about the good old argument that there are people who steal in every government. Even the public realises that this is something else, that corruption is elevated to the level of the state’s functioning in a centralized and monopolised way.

SME/TSS: Are you saying that a rather large part of Hungarian voters perceive corruption as how the state works? How did Orban achieve that?

The rest of this article is premium content at Spectator.sk
Subscribe now for full access

I already have subscription - Sign in

Subscription provides you with:
  • Immediate access to all locked articles (premium content) on Spectator.sk
  • Special weekly news summary + an audio recording with a weekly news summary to listen to at your convenience (received on a weekly basis directly to your e-mail)
  • PDF version of the latest issue of our newspaper, The Slovak Spectator, emailed directly to you
  • Access to all premium content on Sme.sk and Korzar.sk

Get daily Slovak news directly to your inbox

Theme: Viktor Orbán

Read more articles by the topic

Top stories

COVID-19 causes restaurant owners to sell their businesses

Hundreds of gastro facilities are being advertised on real estate websites.

A waiter brings a meal to a customer in a Chinese restaurant in Bratislava on May 20, 2020.

Trianon is a trauma for Hungary even a hundred years later

Slovaks and Hungarians look at the events that led up to the Trianon Treaty differently.

Hungarian delegation is leaving the castle Big Trianon after signing the treaty on June 4, 1920.

Some borders start opening ahead of the summer season (news digest)

Matovič and co. visited Czechia. Even foreigners living in Slovakia can travel to Croatia.

PM Matovič, Deputy PM Veronika Remišová and Foreign Affairs Minister Ivan Korčok on board the flight to Prague for the official visit to the Czech Republic on June 3.

Iconic pharmacy Salvator in Bratislava is closer to new life

Bratislava city council wants to resurrect pharmacy after becoming exclusive owner.

The Salvator pharmacy has been closed for more than two decades.