Slovakia payment to Dutch company overturned

Slovakia will no longer have to compensate Achmea B.V., the shareholder of Union ZP health insurer, for €22 million in damage.

The Union insurance companyThe Union insurance company(Source: Sme - Ján Krošlák)

In the protracted legal dispute between Slovakia and the Dutch company Achmea B.V., the shareholder of Union ZP health insurer, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) published its stance on March 6.

CJEU found that the arbitration clauses included in the international contracts on protection of investments (BIT), in which both parties are European Union member states, are invalid as they are in defiance of the EU law.

This will probably result in the German Supreme Court, which decides on the matter, overturning its earlier verdict, partner of the Taylor Wessing law agency, Andrej Leontiev, told the SITA newswire, adding that the arbitration court had no right to decide on the case. The verdict ordered Slovakia to pay about €22 million in damage compensation to Achmea.

Expert explains the verdict

“As Slovak taxpayers, we are happy about this verdict, but from the point of view of lawyers, it has a bitter taste for us,” Leontiev commented for SITA. “Due to the state of justice in Slovakia, as well as in other eastern-European EU members, we have serious doubts about the ability of local courts to bring just and independent trial to foreign investors in cases concerning protection of investments.” The lawyer also fears that the due verdict could lead to further centralisation of political and judicial power in the hands of the European Commission and the CJEU to the detriment of sovereignty of individual member states.

A bit of litigation history

The Dutch company Achmea B.V. demanded through international courts that Slovakia pay €22 million as a result of the so-called ban on health-insurance companies’ profits during the first government of Prime Minister Robert Fico in 2008. The arbitration court issued a verdict in December 2012, stating that the Slovak republic violated its international contract, but Slovakia appealed it with the Higher Land Court in Frankfurt, and after it refused the appeal, the country turned to the Supreme German Court.

Read also:Achmea loses against SlovakiaRead more 

Slovakia claimed that their international contract with the Netherlands was no longer applicable after the former joined the EU, SITA wrote. Apart from Achmea B. V., the Austrian EURAM Bank AG and Dutch HICEE B.V. also asked for compensation from Slovakia but Slovakia won in every case, even when Achmea B.V. contested the Slovak intention to introduce the system of a single, state-owned health insurer, according to SITA.

Read also:Slovakia faces hefty bill for UnionRead more 

This is an unprecedented decision with an impact on all bilateral investment protection treaties between EU-member states, the Slovak Finance Ministry commented for the TASR newswire. “I believe that this decision means a definitive end to this litigation with Achmea. I’m glad that the courts have agreed with us and accepted our arguments,” said Finance Minister Peter Kažimír. According to the ministry, the court confirmed by its decision that the international arbitration tribunal did not have the power to decide on the dispute between Slovakia and Achmea. For this reason, according to the Finance Ministry, the arbitration ruling should be annulled.

The processing of personal data is subject to our Privacy Policy and the Cookie Policy. Before submitting your e-mail address, please make sure to acquaint yourself with these documents.

Top stories

Gorilla sends Slovaks back to the streets

For a Decent Slovakia protests continued in five locations around Slovakia.

Košice protest on October 18

Nicholson: Only a naive person would believe anything has changed

A former Slovak Spectator and Sme journalist wrote a book about the Gorilla file.

Tom Nicholson

Protests will take place, Pellegrini says Fico can sleep well at night

Read the reactions to the published Gorilla recording.

Smer chair Robert Fico

Two nominees for Record of the Year released within a week

Arguably, only a handful of journalists are likely to hear all 39 hours of Gorilla, but the public will no doubt jump at some sequences.

Protests over the Gorilla scandal drew thousands into Slovakia’s squares.